The concept of the political atmosphere of the manga/anime of One Piece is not mine; the content, however, I will try to make it as original as possible. There will also be spoilers to the Manga and Anime.
I gave up on making a full-blown analysis on the minute details of the Japanese manga/anime of One Piece. Mostly because it was too much content to sift through and examine while also reading back on material for the research. This essay, on the other hand, is more compact and has a central theme to it, a concise recompilation and analysis of the “accidental” political agendas a reader with too much time in his hands sees while reading this odyssey of a story, this epic of modern literature. You may be asking yourself what I am trying to prove here in this essay. And the answer is not an easy one to explain in long form; short form would merely answer half of the continuing question. Such topics as politics, ruling dynamics, racism, revolution, anarchism, and many more all in the span of a youthful story about a boy that wants to become the king of the pirates and the freest man in the world.
Now, summarizing the entire story would take longer than the essay itself; it will be somewhat explained throughout it because almost every arc has a political situation involved, if not in a minor way. Taking that into consideration, be warned that from here on out it will be heavy on spoilers for those that have not read or seen this series. I will try to explain political theory as clearly as possible without being overly pedantic (nor expect readers to be pedantic) or academic because I do not have a background in political science; rather I want it to read as easy as possible for all ages while still keeping the conversation centered on the topic at hand. Discussing the story will only further elongate the essay so minimal knowledge should be applied when reading onwards.
East Blue:
The easiest way to start is with the first instance of corruption and political disturbance found in the very first volume, starting on chapter three. Captain Axe-hand Morgan of the Marines is visibly shown to be an authoritarian autocrat ruling a small island with an iron fist (literally). It first shows that we, as the readers, should not side with the marines because they can easily be persuaded and drunk with power. Autocracy is defined as a governing system enforced and mandated by one force with absolute control. Authoritarianism is basically the same but having himself as the authoritative figure that represses any opposition either by law enforcement or by his own hand. What better way to start than to have Luffy, a lawless young man, dethrone this narcissist that works for the government and yet tortures and enslaves the people he swore to protect.
The next instance is a difficult one to dissect since this one ties in with a future mention that centers more on racism in the backstory. Starting on volume eight we have Arlong park, a rename to Cocoyashi village that is now ruled by fish-men unlawfully, taking land and the moral high-ground with them. In this series, fish-men are superior in strength to humans, yet were enslaved and treated beneath humans for a great part of their history. Now Arlong takes this part of history and flips it upside-down making the people of the village his own slaves. The act itself is racial retribution, taking back what they are owed and the “respect” that comes with it, creating rather a dictatorship in the process. In Luffy’s eyes, he sees this as a harmful action, a naïve view for sure, but one with every individual in mind, not the history behind it and the injustices suffered. Of course, this plays more into a future arc that pertains to the subject and broadens the scope into more of a misguided retaliation from the minorities giving back the dose that they were dealt to innocent civilians.
Let’s revise what Luffy's actions are after each section. In this first section we see that he does not like it when his crew (or those he deems his crew) are threatened, regardless of power or standing. We also see that he doesn’t view people as inherently evil or good, but rather he judges them on their potential and goals. Anyone that goes against his path must get out of the way. His problem is not necessarily with authority (yet) because his dismantlement is out of spite against those that wronged his people and him.
Grand line:
Starting on volume fifteen we have Drum Island, where some of the best doctors reside, and where Wapol has become the ruler. To most Americans this is an easy find because it focuses on the healthcare system and how the ruling class will take it from the proletariat out of spite and disdain. Wapol knowingly takes all of the doctors from this island, letting the people suffer (it must be noted that this island is under snow for most of the year). However, Luffy has no particular interest in what the people want, but what he wants, which is a new crew member. He unknowingly saves the people from this tyrannical governor because it was interfering with his need for a doctor on his ship. Story wise, it is goofy, but if you suspend disbelief for one moment you can see that the author understands the struggles of unaffordable health care in a society that greatly needs it and yet the ruling class minimize the need because they can afford it without a problem. This addresses the American problem of monetizing sickness and death for the pockets of the already wealthy; demonizing socialized healthcare (of course, not directly, but found as a comparative analysis from a reader).
We now hop onto volume seventeen where we find Alabasta, a desert country in need of much help. Here we have kleptocratic autocracy as a country is sucked dry (literally) out of their wealth and resources by a conman with a casino as a front, and the explicit intent to overthrow the current monarchy by discrediting the royals. Kleptocracy is defined as a governing system where the ruler takes from the people with the desire to attain wealth at the expense of the people. Crocodile being an outsider sets up his business and begins to siphon from the natural resources of the country and depleting the people of their rightful need of water. This is happening in the background, as he discredits the current king, inching closer to becoming the new ruler.
And this is without mentioning the public revolt against kleptocracy. Generously speaking, they were not going to solve anything with a coup d’état when Crocodile could wipe an entire town in one hand motion. But still, we see that the people are willing to fight for their right to a just system. This arc reminds me of my home island overthrowing the governor after admitting to poor management (objectively speaking) running a kleptocracy at the behest of the populace, right under our noses.
Next, we have Skypiea starting on volume 26 where the ruler is a theocratic absolutist that wants everyone to venerate him as a god. Eneru forces the people of the sky islands to obey his every whim while threatening them with death by a smiting lightning strike from the heavens above. However, the political concept that is to be focused on is displacement of indigenous people because through a pillar of water a small island is sent up to the sky and Eneru took over it and kicked out the inhabitants of it like a colonizer. The Shandorians will continuously fight for their lands, even if it means going to war against a literal god. It is this search and want for autonomy and emancipation from a megalomaniac that views everyone as beneath him, and yet Luffy somehow comes to save the day by mere happenstance.
Before moving forwards, we must address one thing about our main character and it’s that he is a terrorist in some sense of the word. In the eyes of the government, Luffy is a dangerous man with controversial ideas that will harm the people, he instils fear into the hearts of the navy by his own existence itself. Some might say an altruistic terrorist but that would require intent and knowledge that his is causing distress upon others for the greater good he believes in, which we know Luffy does not possess. However, what solidifies him as a terrorist concerns the next arc.
Water 7, starting on volume 34, enters a long arc filled with so many details and lore to the story of One piece but what’s important to notice is the actions Luffy took from here on out. In the pursuit of rescuing a crewmate, Luffy must go face to face with government elites and as a threat he burns down a flag as a symbol of defiance while also waging a war. This young man declared war on the entire being of the world government just to save his friend, regardless of if it made him a terrorist in the process. This is the only time the enemy is evident to him because he actively sought to fight them with the intent of dismantling. The first instance of revolution from the pirate’s side to be seen, yet not the only or last we shall find in this story.
In between the prior arc we get a backstory to Nico Robin, and we find the truly heinous acts the world government would succumb to in order to maintain their standing as justice in the eyes of the people. This comes because the island of Ohara, known as the island of knowledge, had begun research on what happened 800 years in the forgotten Void Century that the government actively burns and kills for. The navy sent hundreds of men to bombard the entire island including the people for the purpose of eliminating everyone that possesses damning information of the forbidden time. Nico Robin, being the only survivor of this incident. The government plays it off as a civilization searching for ways to destroy the world. A mass genocide over information, knowledge, history. The further solidification of the totalitarian regime the people of this world are subjected to and why the pirates act in opposition to rules. The purposeful desire to withhold history and scientific advancements from the general public in order to save face from the atrocities that were committed in the past. There’s also the obvious need to restrict any further attempt to rise above the status quo the government has already set in motion.
At this stage we know that the world government is not a good system, more so when we continue with the previous arc because any person that is judged at the gates of justice: Enies Lobby. There is a 100% chance of conviction regardless of their actions without a fair trial because any act of insubordination towards them is considered treason and deserves punishment to the full extent of the law. All from petty crime to unspeakable acts erased from the annals of history. They are then sent to Impel Down, a literal inferno modeled after Dante Alighieri’s Divine Comedy where each level downwards gets worse as it progresses. The justice they spout exposed as a farce to the readers in full display.
Within all of the ensuing chaos we finally get a war between pirates and the navy, a battle of wits and determination where honor is held by the strangest of combatants: the pirates. It is in Marine Ford arc (Volume 57) that we see the disparity the author wants us to know about the pirates and the navy is heavily prominent, because we are shown Akainu, an admiral, murdering pirates left and right, while also punishing marines that were fleeting because they should die in battle, honor meaning nothing in war. It is an interesting contrast where honor is for those that view the counterpart as a human, an individual, rather than nothing, a scourge that needs to be rid of. We see how a man fights for his family as the military force fights for pride and the approval of the people. We also get this chilling quote from a dog of the government, Donquixote Doflamingo: “Are pirates the bad guys? Are the navy good guys? Things like those change with the seasons. Kids who never knew peace and kids who never knew war have completely different ideas of right and wrong. It’s the job of those at the top to decide what’s good and evil. Right now, it could go either way. Justice will prevail? Of course it will!! Because the side of justice will be whichever side wins!”.
Let’s derail the conversation for a second and talk about propaganda in One Piece. The world government doesn’t need to work much to persuade the people that pirates are terrible people and that the navy will arrive to save them at any moment. And the pirates don’t make it any harder for the navy to build a good propaganda campaign against them considering that they plunder, steal, destroy, and make life harder for the rest of the people that just want to live a happy life in towns rather than in the ocean. That being said, the world government focuses more on their benevolence rather than the malevolence of the pirates because they need to maintain appearances, as opposed to pirates that do whatever they want without expectations of society. There’s a blurry line in which it’s not actually propaganda and where it is because we know Luffy is not exactly a bad person and yet the government makes him out to be one, while, on the other hand, most of the information provided about pirates is accurate as to how horrible they can be.
Post Time skip:
After two years of training Luffy gets back into the saddle and sails off. Next we have Fishman Island arc (Volume 61) where we deal with a different topic: racism, segregation, revolt, and anarchy. Hody Jones comes from a time where fishmen were threatened to stay as far from humans as possible, while also witnessing the Queen trying to make amends with them to live together on the surface. Hody knows that humans are terrible creatures and sabotages the Queen’s attempt, continuing the cycle of hatred amongst races. It is an interesting view of how there are two ways to wage war against monarchy. Hody believes that he could do a better job than Arlong by amassing power and directly attacking humans rather than staying stagnant as a ruler with slaves. Of course there’s discourse to be had about racial inequality and the need to revolt in order to make the oppressors listen to their demands. However, it was not properly presented throughout the arc and I do not possess the qualifications to talk about these societal issues.
The Dressrosa arc (Volume 70) is the same as the prior arc of Alabasta. We have Donquixote Doflamingo incriminating King Riku Doldo III and taking his place as the king, all to use the island for an underground arms-dealing port while at the surface making the people happy with entertainment. Luffy indirectly saves and clears the name of their hero and king. There’s not much to discuss here since we’ve already seen it before but with a different face, and someone that actually achieved his goal—until Luffy arrives that is.
The most recent arc (Volume 90) is Kaido and Orochi Kurozumi receiving the weapons Doflamingo dealt in a manner of protection. The only difference here is that Wano is an isolated country, and the world government could do nothing to help them, and even so the fact they were not affiliated with the world government made them prime targets to settle and conquer. In part, this arc is an allegory to American colonialism upon Japanese lands. We have a resident menace taking revenge on his family name by ruling the country alongside outside forces after murdering the previous Shogun (military ruler or general from the Heian period of Japan). And in Luffy-fashion, he saves the country after witnessing how the people were treated, the famine, the horrors of scientific experiments, the economic disparity and how they exploit it. It is a sped up version of 100 years of Japanese history with the colonization, the scientific experimentation, seclusion from outside influences and yet joining forces in the long run.
Parties at Play:
The organizations that play a role in this story can be named with one hand. We have the Navy that serves as the World Government, the Pirates, the Revolutionaries, The Celestial Dragons, and the Five elders. Each serving their own motives, be them altruistic, egomaniacal, or selfish.
Let’s begin with the Revolutionaries. Guided by the head, Monkey D. Dragon, father to Monkey D. Luffy and son of Marine Vice admiral Monkey D. Garp. Oda was not very subtle on who he based him on since his ship is directly associated with Che Guevara’s Yacht, Granma (Wind Granma is the name of the revolutionaries’ ship). Dragon’s goal is to free the people from the clutches of the world government and their torment by fighting back. In the canon of the story, Dragon is the most dangerous man in the world due to his ideals and his ways of liberating the people. He is a threat to the status quo the government has stapled for so long.
The Navy comprises several ranks of the marine but also function as the controlling figure of the world, like the police that protects the wealthy. They are the authoritarian force in the foreground fighting against freedom and ideals. The important ranks that mean something are the fleet admiral, the three admirals, commander-in-chief, the five elders, but they serve a different purpose than the marines. There are times where corruption consumes the marines when in power, such as Morgan, and other times when their will is to serve the people and protect them as they’ve sworn, like Coby.
The Five Elders are a special group of rulers that function as figureheads to the world government that go above the fleet admiral and the commander-in-chief. There is not much information on them other than they rule above all and will do anything in their power to maintain their power, as well as keep the Void century a secret from the populace. They, however, work under one individual that is barely known: Imu. This person is the secret ruler of the world, and the Five elders merely help in achieving this goal. Their roles are: Warrior God of Science and Defense, Warrior God of Environment, Warrior God of Justice, Warrior God of Finance, and Warrior God of Agriculture.
Pirates are subdivided into three factions: the four emperors of the sea, the seven warlords, and the adventuring pirates without association. The four emperors are the strongest pirates; no one dares to oppose them, even the navy must get clearance to send several hundred men to wage an entire war against them, wasting resources in the process. The seven warlords are pirates that side with the navy to “fight piracy” in a way (most do as they wish regardless of what the navy tells them to do), pirates till the end; they are the dogs of the marines. And then we have the carefree, pillaging destroyers, the pirates unaffiliated with anyone unless they are under the flag of an emperor.
Finally we have the Celestial Dragons. These are the wealthiest individuals, the ones that hold the most power over the entire world of One Piece. No one can touch them, and the Navy are sworn to protect them at all costs; if they so wish they can call in an admiral on a whim to destroy a town. The celestial dragons are the oldest families that go back to the void century. Everything is theirs because pseudo royalty comes with arrogance and entitlement.
Conclusion:
The main thesis of this essay and overall story is to showcase Luffy in opposition to authority and governing systems that oppress the people, the community, the self, the dreams. Luffy is fundamentally against order, anti-state, a political disruptor, and counter-governance, hence why his dream is to become the freest man in the world, unchained by the social or political ideologies, as long as they do not get in between him and his plans. Not entirely an anarchist but is not opposed to encouraging anarchy when it serves his ideals. It could be some sort of hypocritical anarchism idealism or it’s Oda identifying the duality of anarchism. He is not entirely a terrorist either since there’s no goal to instill fear into others but indirectly creates fear onto the marines. The terrorism Luffy inflicts does not create a vacuum of power because his attacks are mostly on countries that already had prior rulers that were dethroned. Luffy is the embodiment of freedom and liberation, hence why countries have no ill-will against him once he leaves.
There is a complexity to the ruling class in One Piece because there is no one governing system, rather a subsect of one that is under another culminating in a ruler of the world in secret, almost like a pyramidal system. The way the world is separated by islands makes governing a difficult issue in the first place since it takes so much effort to gather the kings, queens, and governors of each one (an estimate of 20 million islands).
Eiichirō Oda introduces left-leaning ideas into his writing in happenstances, for the most part I personally see it as an accident of the writer self-inserting their belief. Of course, some authors have agendas, and push through with the story they create, sending a particular message for the attentive readers and those that wish to learn more about a given topic. You still get the sense that some of them are not accidents, like the obvious allegories against fascism, authoritarian dictatorships, and colonialism. There is definitely, however, a prominent issue with authority and abusive ruling class from the author that is exposed through the writing.
Luffy, as a character and protagonist, reacts to situations rather than actively engaging in conversations. He pulls through with sheer luck which makes him unintentionally (intentionally by the author) the perfect blank slate to explain and showcase ideologies he would be against or in favor of. He changes the world as the world changes around him in a duality of characterization.
I’d like to also point out the small dichotomy of the ideologies present in the story: pirates overall are not the great heroes perceived in the manga; they plundered and raped to their hearts content with the justification that they were completely free individuals. However, the way Oda shows us this is by creating an opposing force that is antithetical in ideology: The authoritarianism of the Marines. Sure, we could say marines are bad and the pirates are good in the story but viewing it as only black and white is meaningless when we have certain characters that embody the true “goodness” and honor the marines espouse, or pirates that truly do not care for what happens to others when they attack and destroy. It is just the role reversal from real life that is seen throughout the story that makes me want to point out this small section.
In essence, titling this an accidentally political story is just misleading. Who am I kidding, this is entirely political in nature. Through allegories and tales, this is a story of revolution, freedom, and sacrifice for what you truly desire. Breaking the chains of authority and actually living a life. Sure, I will concede that it’s not a story for everyone, it is filled to the brim with politics, an intricate storyline that spans nearly three decades, nearly 1200 chapters, A diverse cast of characters with their own ideals and lives. It is an information overload to those that see it at first glance. And that’s okay. Enjoy at your own pace. Just as you enjoyed reading all of this.